Thursday, May 28, 2026

Echoes - Part 1

Lately I’ve been going down a rabbit hole comparing vintage male nude photographs that strongly resemble one another — sometimes almost identically, other times more like riffs on the same visual idea.


Black men standing (back side): 1. Armor II - Herbert List - 1934; 2. Sudanese Nude - George Hoyningen-Huene - 1937


 The deeper I got into my recent Weimar Republic posts, the more I realized how connected these artists actually were. Herbert List clearly influenced photographers like Bruce Weber and Robert Mapplethorpe. List himself was influenced by Swiss sculptor and photographer Karl Geiser


Black men seated (back side): 3. Male Nude (Back Side) - Horst P. Horst - 1952; 4. Ajitto - Robert Mapplethorpe - 1981


And suddenly you start seeing this whole chain of artists quietly borrowing, quoting, studying, imitating, and reshaping each other’s work across generations.


Young blonde men facing each other in the water: 5. Good Friends - Herbert List - 1936; 6. Christian and Jason, Bear Pond - Bruce Weber - 1989


Art critics sometimes treat derivative work like a dirty word, but honestly I see it more like jazz. One artist riffs on another. Somebody picks up an idea and bends it slightly sideways. That’s basically what happened with Cubism when Pablo Picasso and Georges Braque practically started painting each other’s paintings until something new emerged. 


Young men flipping in the water: 7. Untitled - Herbert List - 1958; 8. Ray, John, and Eric, Bear Pond - Bruce Weber - 1989


Photography works that way too. In this first set we begin with black male backsides echoing each other across decades, then move into young men lounging, swimming, and hanging around oceans and cities like variations on the same dream.


Three young men against a wall in shorts: 9. Römisches Model (Roman Model) - Karl Geiser - 1930s; 10. At Newport - Max Dupain - 1952


Some similarities here may be direct references. Others may just reflect artists swimming in the same cultural waters at the same time. Either way, I love seeing how these images “talk” to one another — sometimes separated by continents, sometimes by fifty years.


Muscled shirtless teen pair: 11. Ted Bentley and Dick Kreutel - Bob Mizer - 1950s; 12. Stef - Danny Fitzgerald - 1963


Thoughts?

Please fill in any missing info or corrections.  Most of this info is found online, which can be off.

4 comments:

Doorways

This set explores one of my favorite recurring themes in physique photography: doorways. We start with an unknown model lingering at the thr...